Hinsdale, Clarendon Hills Considering Police Department Merger

The investigation process is in its early stages, according to releases from both villages Thursday.

The Hinsdale and Clarendon Hills police departments may merge services in the future, according to releases Thursday from both villages.

The two villages are discussing combining service for the sake of operational cost savings and a long-term manpower reduction. The merge discussion is in an early phase, according to the releases, and both sides are focused on the “operational and logistical challenges” of such a move.

“In this difficult economic time, the Villages of Clarendon Hills and Hinsdale are committed to looking at new and innovative ways to achieve the high level of services our communities demand,” Clarendon Hills Village President Tom Karaba is quoted in the Clarendon Hills release as saying.

In the Hinsdale release, Village President Tom Cauley makes a similar statement. 

"We believe that consolidation of the Hinsdale and Clarendon Hills police departments will result in significant cost savings to both communities and will provide greater job security to police department employees without in any way compromising the first-rate police services that Hinsdale now enjoys." 

There's no specific time frame on the merge, according to Chief Brad Bloom.

"We're in the perfect position to do this," he said. "We're not facing huge [immediate] budget shortfalls, but we can't continue to operate under this organizational structure."

The chief said he'd be concerned about quality issues if the merge had to be figured out quickly. 

The two police departments regionally share dispatch and tactical response teams, and they assist one another on major investigations already.

Bloom said his department has dealt with budget reductions by laying off two officers in 2010, leaving one position unfilled, converting some positions from full-time to part-time, and increasing its volunteer force.

"We think we’ve gotten as lean as we can be without affecting the services we provide and lessening the quality of the service we provide," Bloom said. "We think [a merger] is the next natural step going forward."

Both releases said the departments have been considering the merge for the past six months, "given the communities’ similar demographics and strong working relationship." The two villages’ fire departments have had an automatic aid agreement since 2010.

There will be obstacles to overcome should the merger idea go forward. Village leaders and police union leaders will both have to be convinced of a merger’s benefits. Bloom said the unions were brought in as a stakeholder early in the process.  

"Certainly communication in something like this is key," Bloom said.

He said he does not think any officers will be laid off as a direct result from the merge. Instead, the new department would reach its optimal number through "attrition and people retiring."

The Illinois Criminal Justice Information Authority (www.icjia.state.il.us/public/) will provide research and legal assistance to the merger effort. 

Bloom did not speculate on what the potential department would be named. Will it be Hinsdale-Clarendon Hills Police or Clarendon Hills-Hinsdale?

"That’s way down the line," the chief said with a chuckle. "That’s not something we’re concerned about yet."

chet everett October 27, 2011 at 07:07 PM
OH PUUHHHLEEZE! This has been a "candidate's question" for the caucuses of both towns for at LEAST a decade if not more. It NEVER gets beyond that because of the simple fact that it is all but impossible for this to really result in any meaningful cost savings. If each town still has a "command structure" that still means there are two well paid Chief of Police positions, handful of senior guys that get the pay / title of "sergeant" and the "regular" officers, of which CH has at most two on the streets at any given time and Hinsdale does not have a whole lot more -- at the end of the day you really don't want fewer officers? They'd need to cover an area that stretch all the way from north of Ogden & 294 to the SW corner of CH around 59th & Western -- not exactly a tidy little area to protect... The tiny amount of savings one MIGHT get from 'closing' the older Hinsdale Police Station would probably enrage the folks that would then be required to trek all the way to the western edge of CH to pay fines and such at its newer station if the physical building was "shared", and how exactly would the "upkeep" of such a shared building work? Imagine the auditing nightmare of Hinsdale tax revenues going toward supporting a structure owned by CH or vice verse? Why the "press release? Perhaps it is an effort to "manage public opinion" on "just how hard we are trying to be innovative" while prepping for a referndum to allow for the elimination of property tax caps...
Joe O'Donnell (Editor) October 28, 2011 at 03:24 PM
Thanks for the comment, Chet. You raise great questions, no doubt. My understanding is that those are the types of things the villages are working on. Clarendon Hills village manager Randy Recklaus said this is something that's pretty unprecedented. Departments have of course shared services, etc., but a complete merge is a pretty new concept. Should they leave it alone and take that as a sign it's more than they bargain for?
RegularGuy October 28, 2011 at 08:50 PM
What could we look forward to if these departments merged? Clarendon Hills would contribute its culture of dishonesty, with officers filing false police reports, ignoring crimes, and allegedly stealing guns from an evidence locker. Hinsdale would contribute its 'revenue first' mentality which says the primary job of the Police Department is to generate fines for the village treasury. Hinsdale also manages to pick and choose which criminal laws it enforces, and which laws it simply ignores. In short, a merged Clarendon Hills - Hinsdale Police Department would leave us with one larger, top-heavy mediocre police force. I can't wait.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something