DREAM Act To Help Some Students, Hurt Many Others
Controversial bill would require U.S. citizens and legal residents to compete with illegal immigrants for financial aid benefits
As high school seniors prepare to submit their college applications, parents across the country are becoming increasingly concerned about how they will afford the skyrocketing price of college tuition and related fees.
Just this year for instance, the University of Illinois raised their tuition rates by 9.5 percent and their fees by an additional 3.2 percent. Conversely, due to budget deficits, approximately 100,000 Illinois students lost up to $4,500 each in state educational grants for the 2010-11 academic year.
In the past, parents and students relied on federal and state financial aid resources to help them cover college tuition, fees and expenses. Beginning January 2011, however, students who are U.S. citizens and legal permanent residents may receive lower financial aid packages if a controversial bill is voted into law next week.
The Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors Act of 2010 or DREAM Act of 2010, sponsored by Senator Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) seeks to repeal a portion of a 1996 immigration law that forbids states from offering illegal immigrants educational benefits that are not also available to U.S. citizens. It would allow illegal immigrants to obtain federal educational loans and compete with the neediest U.S. citizens and legal residents for work-study jobs at colleges.
It would also open the door for states to offer illegal immigrants state educational financial aid resources. Finally, although the bill would not allow illegal immigrants to obtain federal grants during their first two years of college, they would be able to obtain federal grants during their third and fourth years of college.
To be eligible for temporary residency status, illegal immigrants would simply have to show that they graduated high school or obtained the high school equivalency (i.e. GED) and were of good moral character from the date the act was passed. Therefore, even certain convicts would be eligible to become legal residents as long as their convictions occured prior to passage of the Act.
After obtaining a two-year degree or serving in the U.S. military for two years, undocumented immigrants would be able to petition for permanent residency status.
Previous versions of the DREAM Act would have benefitted illegal immigrants who were in the U.S. before the age of 16 and had resided here for at least five years and who were under 35 years old. The House version of the bill, the American Dream Act and the most recent version of the DREAM Act do not have a maximum age clause thus opening up opportunities to countless more illegal immigrants to legalize their status through this act.
Under the older versions of the act, approximately 1.2 million illegal immigrants would be immediately eligible to legalize their status with at least an additional 65,ooo becoming available each year thereafter. Under the new versions, though, it's estimated that up to 2.1 million illegal immigrants would be immediately eligible to legalize their status with many more becoming eligible each year thereafter.
As the bills do not have expiration dates, illegal immigrants would be eligible to legalize their immigration status for decades to come.
Noticeably missing from each of over a dozen prior DREAM Act type bills is any language that would add funds to the federal financial aid program. If passed, current and future U.S. citizen and legal resident beneficiaries of federal financial aid would have to compete for existing financial aid dollars with up to 2.1 million illegal immigrants newly added to the federal financial aid rolls effectively lowering the award amounts for some while eliminating the awards altogether for others.
Although the DREAM Act has been around in various versions since 2000, Congress has never conducted a cost analysis of the act and so there is no solid figure of how much the bill would cost the U.S. taxpayer. Students are able to borrow up to $9,500 per year in federal loans. If just 1.2 million of the estimated 2.1 million illegal immigrants who would immediately benefit from the act applied for student loans, the federal government would have to lend approximately $19.2 billion for the first two years of the act alone.
These figures would increase exponentially the third year after passage because the illegal immigrants would then be eligible for federal grants as well of up to another $9,500 annually per student. These figures do not include funds illegal immigrants would receive under the federal work study program.
Unless millions of new jobs were created for all these newly legalized workers (and none were lost), it's expected that many would default on their student loans. Currently, the student loan default rate is hovering at about 7 percent.
Aside from adding millions of more people into the federal financial aid rolls without increasing funding for the program, the DREAM Act would also grant illegal immigrants authorization to work, to collect welfare, medicare, social security and unemployment benefits among other benefits. They would be able to petition for their family members to immigrate to the U.S. as well.
Interestingly enough, foreign students legally in the U.S. would still be required to cover their own educational costs. Furthermore, despite the fact that legal international students typically have advanced degrees, have a history of following our laws and regulations and would be cheaper to legalize since they've already paid for their own educational expenses, no new mechanism would be added to allow them to become legal residents in the U.S.
U.S. Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.) has repeatedly stated that she would vote in favor of the DREAM Act if it came up for a vote in the House. She and other amnesty proponents claim that the bill would educate millions who in turn would be able to start their own businesses for instance.
Opponents of the bill question whether its wise to offer a bailout-type bill for illegal immigrants when more than 14 million Americans are unemployed and many more are underemployed. Additionally, the bill would not require beneficiaries to major in any specific fields so, theoretically, illegal immigrants would receive permanent residency status for completing a general associate degree which could include classes in bowling and basket weaving; hardly the training required to jumpstart the flailing economy through entrepreneurship.
The DREAM Act has been added to the lame-duck Congress' agendas in both houses and is expected to pass in the final days of the Democrat-controlled Congress. Debate on the bill will begin as early as Monday.
If passed, it would be the eighth immigration amnesty/legalization bill to pass in 24 years and would still leave open the possibility of a larger amnesty bill that would address the plight of the remaining 10 million to 18 million illegal immigrants currently in the U.S. who would not be eligible to legalize under the DREAM Act.
Writer's note: As a Latino male, I understand the sensitivities of race relations in the U.S. Please note that no references to race or culture have been made within this piece.
Eddie A
2:28 pm on Monday, November 29, 2010
The youth who will be able to benefit from the DREAM will not be able to apply for Pell Grants, on Loans. They will not be able to get their hands on FAFSA, and will not steal any college seats--since we know colleges accept students according to required criteria. They will not have the chance to petition any family members, and will not be eligible for welfare.
This is how it works:
If the person qualifies for the DREAM act, he/she will be given conditional status for 5 years, in those five years he/she will have to complete 2 years of college (I do believe it should be changed to 4 years, though) or two years of military service, if he/she completes this requirement he/she will be able to apply for a permanent resident card, not for citizenship.
The DREAM act is not an amnesty since it will only cover people who have been here for at least 6 years prior to turning 16, so someone who has recently migrated will not be eligible since he/she had to be here six years prior to the passage of this bills. Moral character is also a requirement. I FULLY support the DREAM Act.
Frank Medina
12:59 am on Tuesday, November 30, 2010
Eddie, based on your comments alone, it is quite obvious that you lack any real knowledge and experience with US immigration law & procedure as well as with the financial aid process.
For DREAMers to obtain loans for college, they have to apply for them through the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA). They would not be eligible for federal grants during their first two years of college but would be able to access grants after completing their second year of congress. Illegal aliens who've already completed two years of college would automatically be eligible for federal grants. Furthermore, the bill doesn't keep them from being awarded state grants like Illinois' MAP award. Finally, illegal aliens would compete directly with the neediest US citizens and legal residents for jobs under the work study program which are also initiated through the FAFSA.
Besides being a BAILOUT for ILLEGAL ALIENS, the DREAM Act is in fact an amnesty as it forgives prior unlawful behavior. In fact, it specifically permits some convicted criminal aliens to receive legal residency status. Read the text of the bill, I'm not making any of this stuff up!
Before even stepping foot on a college campus, these illegal aliens would receive conditional residency status that'll allow them to receive welfare, unemplyment, medical and other entitlement benefits. They'd also receive authorization to work even though we already have 15 million unemployed or underemployed Americans.
Ingrid Durham
4:05 pm on Monday, November 29, 2010
I wrote to Senator Durbin regarding the DREAM Act several years ago. My parents immigrated to the United States over 50 years ago. As soon as they became eligible, they applied for citizenship. They worked at blue collar jobs their entire lives. I didn't get a dime for college, not from the government and not from my family. I worked and paid my tuition while going to school. How is this fair?
Zen
6:58 pm on Monday, November 29, 2010
It frustrates me that people who went to school years ago, say like 15 or 20 years ago, compare the time they were in school to today's time. Times are DIFFERENT. Tuition back then was not as expense as it is today. My cousin went to UCSB in the 1990s and paid way less than what my friend is currently paying at UCSB.
Frank Medina
12:37 am on Tuesday, November 30, 2010
Zen,
I think her comment wasn't as much about reminiscing as it was about how she was able to overcome obstacles on her own, without handouts. Yo also cleverly failed to acknowledge the biggest difference between her and DREAMers: her family immigrated here LEGALLY!
It's funny that you mentioned UCSB because a few years ago, California, like Illinois, passed a law allowing illegal aliens to pay the lower in state tuition. Therefore, if I, a law abiding veteran of both the US Navy and the US Army were to attend UCSB, I'd pay nearly double the tuition rate that an illegal alien would pay at UCSB.
As stated in the article, the DREAM act hurts US citizens and legal residents and at the end of the day, does nothing to prevent future illegal immigration from occurring.
Thanks for your comments.
Steve Woodward
10:33 pm on Monday, November 29, 2010
The DREAM act is a liberal scheme to spawn future generations of reliable Democrat voters. It is all about expanding the Entitlement Class in America. Plain and simple.
Frank Medina
12:44 am on Tuesday, November 30, 2010
Steve, one could easily blame this on the democrats but that would be irresponsible as the original author of the DREAM Act was Senator Orrin Hatch (R-UT). Also, former President George W. Bush also was an advocate for the DREAM Act and amnesty for illegal aliens.
Finally, the first of the seven amnesty/legalization programs for illegal aliens was proposed by and passed under none other than Republican Ronald Reagan.
Incidently, the DREAM Act would be the eighth amnesty/legalization program for illegal aliens since 1986. Over 9 million illgal aliens have legalized their status since then and all that has done is exacerbate the problem. We now have between 12-18 million illegal aliens in the US and Congress has not come up with any viable plans to stop the flow.
Therefore, politicians from both sides of the aisle are to blame for this problem.
Thanks for your comments.
Frank Medina
12:42 am on Thursday, December 2, 2010
I have thoroughly enjoyed our discussion on here and thank you all so much for your participation in this important debate. Unfortunately, this debate is now old news. A new DREAM Act bill was introduced Tuesday evening and its provisions are significantly different from those in previous bills. I want all of you to be a part of several follow up articles on the topic (I won't be the author on all of them). If you'd be interested in being interviewed for a future article on the DREAM Act, email me with your contact information. Simply click the "Email the Author" link under the article title above. Thanks again. - frank